Weeds as Soil Indicators

A criticism of soil tests is that they are only as good as the sample. While taking a sample, only a small representative fraction of a field's soil is analyzed. In this way, observing prominent plant populations gives a fuller understanding of soil conditions, as certain plants generally inhabit a specific type of soil and can be a useful tool for a farmer or gardener.  (HKRL Editor)

Tanja Folnovic

Agronomy Expert

Farmers constantly battle with the weeds, but weeds can have a useful purpose - they can be used as a soil indicators. Simply by observing the most prevalent weeds that are growing in a specific area, they can indicate if the soil is acidic or alkaline, whether the soil is a healthy, balanced or if it’s depleted.  Weeds can indicate a poorly draining soil, or a soil that is unable to retain moisture.  Weeds can even indicate if the soil is unbalanced, being overly rich in one nutrient and deficient in others. 

When using weeds as a soil indicator, observe several of the most prevalent types of weeds to get an accurate soil assessment. If on cultivated field suddenly appears certain weed species, i.e. if this type is dominating, it indicates mistakes in cultivation technology management and soil condition. For example, field horsetail, field mint and creeping buttercup indicate severe soil compaction and excess moisture, while nettles and chickweed indicate that the soil is rich in humus.  

Individual weeds that indicate a soil’s nutrient values are useful in determining if the soil is unbalanced. Annual bluegrass indicates very low calcium, low humus, low bacterial count and high magnesium levels. Burdock grows in soils very high in iron and sulfate and very low levels of calcium and manganese. Buckhorn plantain indicate very low levels of calcium, low humus levels and very high in chlorine, magnesium, potassium, and sodium. Common and mouse ear chickweed indicate very low calcium and phosphorus levels and very high potassium and sodium levels. Crabgrass indicates very low levels of calcium and phosphorus, low pH, low humus, very high chlorine levels and high levels of magnesium and potassium.

The use of weeds as soil indicators is not a new concept. In 50 AD, the great Roman scholar, Pliny the Elder observed that land supporting wild plum, elder, oak, and thimbleberry was also favourable for wheat production. Many North American immigrants chose land for their farms according to the vegetation it supported. They quickly recognized that white pine communities were characteristic of sandy soils of little agricultural value, whereas forests of birch, beech, maple, or hemlock indicated more fertile soils.

This can be especially valuable when bringing new land into cultivation as it helps inform the techniques to employ and the soil conditioners to incorporate. However, to get an accurate assessment of soil condition, it should determine which weed type is dominant or observe a few common species. For example, the dandelion and common mullein both indicate an acidic soil, but common mullein can also mean a low fertility soil, so if you see it alone, it could mean several things, but seeing it along with dandelions would indicate an acidic soil. For an existing plot, the changes in preponderance of certain weeds over time can provide a subtle, but useful gauge to the health or otherwise of the soil.

There will always be a battle between man and weed, but knowing that weeds can be used not only as a soil indicator, but also the flower of many weeds provide essential nectar and pollen, the foods needed by beneficial insects to complete their life cycle.In the table below you can see a list of weeds that show a particular soil condition and its nutritional status

In the table below you can see a list of weeds that show a particular soil condition and its nutritional status.

The Ecological Agriculture Project in Montreal, Canada has published the following table containing valuable information
on this subject. Unfortunately, the quality of the table is poor but the information is very pertinent. 


Identifying weeds takes practice. The following are some resources which will get you going in the right direction. Each locality may have its own distinctive plants so develop a relationship with a neighboring farmer or department of agriculture.

The definition of a weed is simply an unwanted plant

but if one can become adept in identifying them

-- and what they mean -- 

they can add an important tool in your arsenal of

successful farming.